Yes, 11 times. See the list of recipients of great answer badges . The user papes of the respective users should lead you to actual instances. Two I happen to know by heart are on constants that turned out to be rational (Gjergji's answer) and a proof without words by Mariano.
]]>http://i54.tinypic.com/2cgd3k2.jpg
I wonder if this would also happen when an answer goes above +100 --- has that ever happened?
]]>