Vanilla 1.1.9 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.
(Continuing from here, though it's probably irrelevant now.)
MathOverflow gets a fair number of questions that are not research-level, and are quickly closed. In most cases, this seems to happen because the user thinks MO is the math equivalent of Stack Overflow, and does not know what sort of questions are acceptable. Part of the reason I think is that the "Ask a Question" page does not mention anything about this: there is a "Please read the FAQ…" message, but it's almost an axiom of user-interface design that no one reads instructions! There is a "How to write math" on the right, and it has happened that some newbie spent a lot of time learning LaTeX and formatting a question carefully, only to have it quickly closed. On Stack Overflow's Ask a Question, there is a brief message to the right on what sort of questions to ask — in the place where MO has "How to write math". It continues to be displayed while you type the question title, and only when you start typing the text of the question does the message change to formatting instructions. Something like this would be easy to implement here too, I think?
Of course, once math.stackexchange.com goes into Public beta tomorrow, this will probably be less of a problem, but I still think it would be polite and nicer to people who arrive here by mistake to clarify all this (and direct them elsewhere) on the Ask a Question page. There's no guarantee that everyone will read the more visible instructions either, but it's a trivial change that could help quite a bit.
What might be nice is a nag screen that turns off once you hit 100-200 reputation.
Though I feel silly bringing up a trivial feature again, I see currently a lot of closed questions on the front page by people who don't seem to have noticed this is not the right place to ask, so I'm bumping this thread up. What do others think?
I feel every bit helps. Having to close/deal with these questions is a waste of time for regular users of MathOverflow, and a rude shock to those who ask them.
Now that math.stackexchange.com exists (see its ask a question page), we could also just point people there. Proposed wording (just an arbitrary start):
Is your question about research-level mathematics?
If not, ask on math.SE or [FAQ section]We prefer questions that be answered, not just discussed.
Be precise. Provide background and motivation.
Please read the FAQ and How to Ask page.
(In fact, even simply mentioning "research-level mathematics" anywhere on the Ask a Question page would be a great improvement, I suspect.)
1 to 4 of 4