Not signed in (Sign In)

Vanilla 1.1.9 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

  1.  

    Ideally, is one supposed to accept an answer even for a community-wiki question for which, by definition, there is no single right answer? I looked at a few of the most popular big-list questions on MO and did not see a de facto consensus on the matter. I ask because common sense suggests that it is ridiculous for me to, say, accept one of the 50+ answers to my recent question about the Museum of Mathematics as the "right answer"; at the same time, I get the vibe that one is always "supposed" to accept an answer unless no satisfactory answers are provided.

  2.  

    I don't think it is necessary, and I would discourage it in most cases. There have been some big-list CW questions where one answer was accepted from a large pool, and to me, the choice often seemed to be rather strange and arbitrary.

    If I remember correctly, designating a CW answer as accepted does not award any points to the account that started the answer.

  3.  

    I agree with Scott. It almost always strikes me as really weird when a CW question has an accepted answer.

  4.  

    There's of course the one exception to the rule: when the question gets edited too many times by the OP....